Public broadcasters are unashamedly taking sides in Germany’s national elections by effectively blocking the second most popular party, the right-wing, anti-immigration Alternative für Deutschland (AfD) from participating in the main TV debate.
The channels ARD and ZDF have decided to only invite Chancellor Olaf Scholz—the Social Democrats’ lead candidate—and opposition leader Friedrich Merz of the centre-right CDU to take part in a live televised debate on February 9th next year. Their reasoning: the CDU/CSU alliance is clearly ahead of all the other parties in opinion polls, and Merz is Scholz’s main rival.
The opposition alliance may be clearly leading in opinion polls (it is currently at 31.5%), but it is not Scholz’s SPD—at 16.5%—but the right-wing AfD that has been consistently in second place for the past one-and-a-half years. It currently has the support of a fifth (19.5%) of the electorate, which should merit a place for its lead candidate, Alice Weidel, in the televised debate. A spokesman for the party said they would sue the broadcasters for failing to take the party seriously.
The party was sidelined in 2021, too, when ARD and ZDF invited Scholz and the lead candidates of the CDU and the Greens to take part in the debate.
The AfD does not have a real chance of entering government, because all the other parties refuse to cooperate with it, but it is not the job of the publicly funded media—which are supposed to be neutral and politically impartial—to decide AfD’s fate.
The right-wing party was not the only one that expressed its furore at being ignored. The Greens, who are a part of the outgoing government, are polling at 11.5% in fourth place, and also demand a place at the debate. ARD and ZDF had originally intended for their lead candidate, Robert Habeck, to debate AfD’s Alice Wiedel in a separate TV programme, but Habeck declined the invitation.
The leader of the Greens’ parliamentary group, Katharina Dröge, criticised the public broadcasters, saying
Are ARD and ZDF serious? To invite only the SPD & CDU? Is the grand coalition getting friendly support? What kind of country is that supposed to represent?
The private broadcaster RTL and news magazine Stern have also invited Friedrich Merz and Olaf Scholz to a separate debate on February 16th. RTL also announced that it is “currently in talks” with the chancellor and leading candidates of other parties regarding further debates.
National elections are to be held on February 23rd, seven months earlier than scheduled. The call for a vote was necessitated by the collapse of the current government.
